English Language Arts
Grade 7
15 min
Choose evidence to support a claim
Choose evidence to support a claim
What you'll learn
- Identify at least three pieces of textual evidence from a given article that are relevant to a specific claim with 80% accuracy.
- Explain in writing how each selected piece of evidence logically supports a given claim, using clear and concise language, in at least two out of three opportunities.
- Evaluate the strength of different pieces of evidence in supporting a claim, ranking at least three pieces of evidence from strongest to weakest with reasonable justification in writing.
- Apply the skill of selecting and explaining evidence to support a claim by constructing a short paragraph arguing for or against a given statement, using at least two pieces of evidence and clear explanations.
Tutorial Preview
1
Introduction & Learning Objectives
Learning Objectives
Identify the main claim in a given text or prompt.
Distinguish between relevant and irrelevant evidence for a specific claim.
Evaluate the strength and credibility of different types of evidence.
Select appropriate textual evidence (quotes, paraphrases) from literary texts.
Select appropriate factual evidence (statistics, examples) from informational texts.
Explain how chosen evidence effectively supports a claim.
Ever tried to convince someone of something without any proof? 🤔 It's tough, right?
In this lesson, you'll learn how to pick the best evidence to make your arguments strong and convincing, whether you're analyzing a story or making a point in an essay. This skill is crucial for clear communication and persuasive writing in all s...
2
Key Concepts & Vocabulary
TermDefinitionExample
ClaimA statement that asserts something to be true, often requiring proof or support.The main character in 'The Outsiders' changes significantly by the end of the novel.
EvidenceFacts, examples, quotes, statistics, or other information used to support a claim.A quote from Ponyboy's narration showing his changed perspective.
RelevanceHow closely related and applicable the evidence is to the specific claim it's supposed to support.If your claim is about Ponyboy's change, evidence about Dally's actions would be less relevant than evidence about Ponyboy's thoughts.
SufficiencyHaving enough evidence to convince the audience that the claim is true and well-supported.Providing only one quote might not be sufficient; you might need several...
3
Key Rules & Conventions
The 'Direct Link' Rule (Relevance)
Evidence must directly relate to and logically support the specific claim it's trying to prove.
Before selecting evidence, ask yourself: 'Does this piece of information directly answer or prove my claim?' If you can't explain the connection, it's probably not strong enough or relevant.
The 'Enough is Enough' Rule (Sufficiency)
Always provide enough evidence to make your claim convincing, but don't overwhelm your audience with unnecessary details.
Use multiple pieces of evidence or detailed examples to build a strong case. One piece of evidence is rarely enough for a complex claim, but too many can make your writing feel cluttered.
The 'Trustworthy Source' Rule (Credibility)
A...
4 more steps in this tutorial
Sign up free to access the complete tutorial with worked examples and practice.
Sign Up Free to ContinueSample Practice Questions
Challenging
Claim: 'The protagonist, a young wizard named Alistair, is both powerful and reckless.' Which PAIR of quotes, used together, provides the most sufficient evidence for the entire claim?
Quote 1: 'Alistair muttered the incantation, and a torrent of fire erupted from his hands, far larger than he had intended.'
Quote 2: 'He spent hours in the library, poring over ancient spellbooks.'
Quote 3: 'He ignored the master wizard's warning and entered the Forbidden Forest alone.'
Quote 4: 'Alistair was known for his kindness to magical creatures.'
A.Quote 1 and Quote 3
B.Quote 2 and Quote 4
C.Quote 2 and Quote 3
D.Quote 1 and Quote 4
Challenging
Text: 'The construction of the Grand Canal in ancient China was a monumental undertaking. While it required immense labor and resources, often from conscripted peasants, its completion unified the economies of the north and south. It allowed grain to be transported easily to feed the capital and armies, preventing famines and strengthening the empire's stability.'
Claim: 'Despite its high human cost, the Grand Canal was ultimately beneficial to the Chinese empire.'
Which piece of evidence from the text best supports this complex claim?
A.The canal 'required immense labor and resources, often from conscripted peasants.'
B.The canal 'allowed grain to be transported easily... preventing famines and strengthening the empire's stability.'
C.The canal's construction 'was a monumental undertaking.'
D.The canal connected the 'economies of the north and south.'
Challenging
A student is writing an essay with the claim: 'The main character's journey symbolizes the transition from childhood to adulthood.' They choose the following evidence: 'He trembled as he approached the dark cave, but still stepped inside.' The student's choice of evidence is flawed because it best supports a different claim. Which common pitfall does this represent?
A.The evidence is misinterpreted; it directly supports a claim about bravery, not necessarily the transition to adulthood.
B.The evidence is insufficient; one action cannot prove a symbolic journey.
C.The evidence is not credible; it's from a fictional story.
D.The evidence is irrelevant; it has nothing to do with growing up.
Want to practice and check your answers?
Sign up to access all questions with instant feedback, explanations, and progress tracking.
Start Practicing FreeMore from Additional Topics
English Language Arts for other grades
Frequently asked questions
What grade level is "Choose evidence to support a claim"?
Choose evidence to support a claim is a Grade 7 English Language Arts lesson on ExcelOS.
What will I learn in Choose evidence to support a claim?
You'll be able to: Identify at least three pieces of textual evidence from a given article that are relevant to a specific claim with 80% accuracy; Explain in writing how each selected piece of evidence logically supports a given claim, using….
Is "Choose evidence to support a claim" free to practice?
Yes. You can read the tutorial preview for free, and signing up for a free ExcelOS account unlocks the full tutorial and all practice questions with instant feedback.
How many practice questions are included with Choose evidence to support a claim?
This lesson includes 25 practice questions across multiple difficulty levels, each with instant feedback and explanations.